|
Can You Say "I Love You"?
by Roberta Maisel
 In
the movie of Pearl Buck's epic novel,
The Good Earth, Wang Lung, the young protagonist, hears his wife
cooing happily to their new-born baby and telling it how wonderful it is. The
new father looks up to the heavens and, in a voice full of bluster and feigned
anger, tells the Almighty not to listen to her, to recognize that this is only a
plain, ordinary baby, a no-account baby. Then he chastises his wife for playing
with fire, for tempting the gods.
Human sacrifice -- and, in particular, infant sacrifice -- may be the
dawn-of-time precursor of the taboo against praising a child. We don't want to
push our luck, the gods may turn against us, against the whole community. If we
act as though our delicate and precious and utterly amazing offspring were
nothing much, maybe God will give it health and long life. We have avoided the
presumption that our child may be better, smarter, handsomer, or stronger than
others in the community.
Another source of the taboo against praising your child is the notion that
praise will go to her head: she will know she's smart, he will know he is
good-looking. Both will become conceited and resented by the community as a
result of this knowledge. Parents down-pedal their offsprings' talents and
strengths in public, not wanting to show off too much (although grandparents are
allowed some leeway vis-a-vis their grandchildren). But, more importantly, they
often don't express praise and admiration for their children's talents and
strengths in private, to their child's face, where over-pridefulness is not at
issue.
Make no mistake, children of all ages never tire of hearing praise from their
parents. In my interviews with adult children, a recurring theme was parents'
failure to validate or even to recognize their children's accomplishments,
including the ongoing stuff of their lives.
The importance of praise -- sometimes referred to as strokes -- cannot be
overstated. But there are problems in giving compliments. Flax and Ubell point
out that "the trouble with these compliments is that they carry a hidden
message." The implied message from the parents is: "I know what's good for you,
and I will tell you when you are doing well. If I withhold praise, therefore,
you'll know you are doing something wrong." Furthermore, even young children
detect insincerity. You don't want to be caught making flattering remarks to
your adult child that you don't feel. What do you say to your son when he shows
you an assemblage that he has created that you think is an example of the very
worst type of modern art? How do you react when your 32-year-old daughter
parades her latest outfit which is an ill-fitting, stretched, and wrinkled
garment that looks to you as though it came out of the free box at the homeless
shelter?
Below are some guidelines relating to sincerity that should help you to give
praise more freely to your adult child:
• You don't have to like something that your son or daughter does in order to
give her praise. Ask her to explain web site design, rain forest action
networks, or Barbie doll collector's clubs. By merely showing interest and
listening to her explanations you are providing acknowledgment and validation.
Your daughter will hear it as though it were praise.
• Tell him "It's you!" You wouldn't have twelve antique clocks in your living
and dining rooms all ticking and bonging away at once with no let-up, but to
your son, the clock collector and restorer, this is nirvana. Enjoy his
uniqueness, his enthusiasm, his knowledge, his craft. He doesn't need to be like
you. He needs to be himself, and would like your acknowledgment for his
individuality.
• Do yourself a favor and learn about current cultural icons, trends, and
changes in perception. Recognize that we are all stuck in our pasts to some
extent. If you were a teenager in the '40s or '50s you may have not have noticed
when the Beatles, Bob Dylan, and the Grateful Dead arrived on the scene. But for
someone born in 1954 or 1958 or 1963, these musicians were larger-than-life,
more than entertainment, more than dance bands. You will need to know something
about the significant cultural landmarks in your child's past. You may want to
bone up on the loosening of sexual mores, including co-ed dormitories and
cohabitation without marriage, as well as recreational drug use, rock/rap music,
and even widespread computer literacy. All of these things, and more, have
influenced your adult child's life. You will need to know about them if you are
going to give him validation, recognition, and praise.
• Sincerity, after all, grows out of love. If you love your adult child you
can appreciate her accomplishments even if they are widely divergent from things
you consider valuable or beautiful.
Ellen's daughter, Grace, threw every spare dime into equipment for her
darkroom. She worked as a waitress but photography was her passion. She took
close-ups of plants, the results being more-or-less geometric designs. Ellen
didn't know what to make of Grace's expensive, time-consuming hobby. The
pictures seemed endlessly repetitive. Grace didn't enter competitions, have
gallery showings or sell any pictures. She didn't even hang any on her walls.
Ellen wanted to say, "This is not leading anywhere. Try something else," but
she held her tongue. She loved her 30-year-old daughter and sensed Grace's
pride in her craft. She heard herself saying, one day, "I admire you, Grace,
for your devotion to this work. I couldn't do it." Grace beamed.
Saying "I love you" to your adult child
Many parents now in their fifties and sixties grew up in homes where their
parents never said "I love you" to them. This provocative finding emerged from
an interview cohort of midlife parents too small to be statistically
significant, but I think it is important nonetheless. Not a single interviewee
remembered being told "I love you" by his or her parents even once. Why should
this be so? What is it about saying, flat out, "I love you" to our children that
has been shunned by many and may still constitute a taboo among middle-aged
parents today?
"Do my parents love me?" is a deep and emotionally-charged question which
most people would rather avoid. Either a Yes or a No answer to the question may
be incomplete and unsatisfying. We can say, "Yes, of course they love me. They
fed, housed, and clothed me. They raised me to adulthood. They're my parents. Of
course they love me." We may also say, "My insides tell me that my parents
really never loved me. At bottom I feel unloved, unwanted, not okay. Maybe they
tried, maybe they were convinced that they loved me very much. But something
went wrong."
Provoked by my interview data, I wrestled with the following questions: To
what extent is self-esteem influenced or buttressed by the utterance of "I love
you" by the parents? Further, are there functional equivalents of the three
little words -- kissing, hugging, touching, and holding -- that render the words
merely one variant of expression of affection? Can a child feel deeply and
securely loved and appreciated without ever hearing the words "I love you" from
her parents?
Many of my adult child respondents could not remember hearing the phrase used
in their home. Not only did their parents refrain from saying it to the children
but they also didn't say it to each other. One respondent felt there was a
distinct sexual connotation to the phrase "I love you" and that fathers,
especially, refrain from saying it to their daughters.
Novels, movies, indeed most cultures (both high and low) invest "I love you"
with strong erotic content. Of course, we can use the phrase to express close
friendships or parent-child bond. Or we can use it lightly, frivolously -- as
some Hollywood stars are reputed to use the word "dahling." Nevertheless, the
deep, romantic, feeling-tone of the phrase reinforces the taboo against its use
by parents and adult children.
Saying "I love you" to one's sons reveals a different, though related taboo,
a taboo against perceived threats to manliness. Sons, in our culture, are
supposed to absorb the male values of strength, action orientation, and
assertiveness, and not to place too much reliance on feeling. Over-sensitivity
in males is discouraged. Saying "I love you" to boys as they are growing up may
be seen as a "female" thing leading to softness, gentleness (heaven forbid), and
the dreaded "sissy" epithet.
I suspect that many parents would like to tell their children openly that
they love them, both in their childhood and in their adult years, but feel
constrained from doing so. They may do a wide variety of things to try to convey
the same message -- giving gifts, services, advice, warm smiles -- but the three
little words themselves are avoided.
A person growing up in such a home may unconsciously imitate his parents when
he has children, and perpetuate the taboo. Saying "I love you" is felt to be
inappropriate or even wrong. Alternatively, he may make a conscious attempt to
openly declare his love for his children regularly. I would like to believe that
this can work, that people can break away from the legacy of this taboo without
fear and without bad consequences for parent or child. To break out of the cycle
of constraint, it may be useful to see how the taboo works.
When we say "I love you" to someone, anyone, we are giving them a great gift.
If this gift were not routinely given to us, we probably wouldn't pass it along
to others. Because we don't have to give it: it is, by definition, freely given.
It is something bigger than a birthday present (a well-accepted ritual) or a
holiday phone call. It is not a social nicety. It is not supported by custom
(although it need not go against custom). It is, importantly, three little
words, not ten or fifteen little words (I love you because you're such a nice,
cute, little girl, etc.). Because there are only these three, unqualified words,
we are saying, "Right here and right now, all of me is giving my love to all of
you."
So powerful and potent is the phrase in our culture that it is, sadly,
sometimes avoided even in romantic love relationships, most frequently by men.
Saying "I love you" involves devotion and commitment. It opens the door to
intimacy. We may well ask, "Is it possible that many parents shy away from
intimacy with their children?"
My interviews have shown that the parental taboo against saying "I love you"
to one's young children carries over to adolescent and adult children. The adult
child may then have great difficulty in saying "I love you" to her parents. One
of the most strongly held feelings around this issue is embarrassment. There is
something invasive, a kind of emotional nakedness, that clings to the phrase "I
love you" that causes many adults to avoid it. It may also be that by saying "I
love you" people feel themselves at risk of being rebuffed. The other party may
not be able to reciprocate. That hurts a lot.
If fear of rebuff is really at the heart of this taboo, then the questions of
who says the three little words first and, subsequently, who says them more
often, become heartfelt issues. This is more apparent in romantic relationships,
in which, typically, each party requires proofs of devotion or at least signs of
affection in order to bring out declarations of love from the other. But however
different the parent/adult child relationship is from the romantic one, the fear
of rebuff, and it's offshoot, pride in not needing anyone's affection, are very
much the same in both.
It is no fun to put oneself out to another, whether it be one's children,
one's parents, or a casual acquaintance, and discover that they don't respond in
kind. One of my respondents told me the following vignette:
She and her father were sitting on the steps of the family's summer cabin
in Vermont, watching a beautiful sunset, listening to the country sounds of
insects and birds, enjoying the idyllic setting.
Jean remembered this scene with pain and regret twenty years later, this
scene where nothing happened -- precisely because nothing happened. She wanted
to put her arms around her father and say something along the lines of, "Gee,
Dad, I love you." She imagined he felt a similar longing. But both of them let
the moment pass.
I suspect that a combination of embarrassment and unwillingness to take that
tiny risk of rebuff were what kept the interaction from flowering. It is
certainly possible to feel warmth and togetherness in the silence of a sunset.
But if a person wishes to say "I love you" and simply cannot say the words, a
serious, culturally-based, interpersonal problem is being revealed.
The truth about loving is that it is infinitely replenishable and the more we
give, the more we have to give. But many people don't know this. I suspect many
feel that if they give love too freely they will be depleted, and they must hold
back from explicitly committing themselves to a gift of love by not saying "I
love you."
Can we, then, make the leap and say that there is nothing that can equal the
regular use of the phrase "I love you" with our children? I cannot, in all
fairness, suggest that the total panoply of loving gestures shown by parents to
their children does not send the complete message if it lacks frequent use of
the spoken phrase. But I am haunted by the way in which the phrase seems to
break down barriers to intimacy and break through to something profoundly
healing.
You may want to wrestle with the "I love you" issue by answering the
questions below. Get personal. Ask yourself how the taboo works, in what ways
you partake of it and how you might be able to extricate yourself from it if you
feel its constraints.
• Did your parents regularly say "I love you" to you?
• Do you say it to your adult children?
• If not, would it help your relationship if you were to do so?
• Do you feel constrained, embarrassed, or awkward at the thought of saying
"I love you" to them?
• If yes, can you think why this might be?
• Do they say it to you?
• If so, does it make you feel good to hear it?
You might be surprised to discover that you would like to say "I love you" to
them, and that you would be very pleased to hear your adult children say it to
you, if they don't already do so.
This
article is excerpted from All Grown Up, ©2001, by Roberta Maisel.
Reprinted with permission of the publisher, New Society Publishers.
http://www.newsociety.com
Info/Order this book.
About the Author
 ROBERTA
MAISEL is a volunteer mediator with Berkeley Dispute Resolution Service in
Berkeley, California. She is an enthusiastic parent of three grown children and,
at various times in her life, has been a school teacher, antique shop owner,
piano accompanist, and political activist working with and for Central American
refugees, homeless people and Middle East peace. She has given talks and
workshops on aging, living with loss, and getting along with adult children.
When she became widowed in 1993 at the age of 58, her life changed direction and
she found what she thinks of as a new calling - writing. Her children have been
a deep source of inspiration and insight.
Printer Friendly Page |