Why Is It So Stressful To Talk Politics With The "Other Side"?


Tomb of the Ribaudo family, monumental cemetery of Genoa, Italy, famous for the cover of the single of the English band Joy Division's " Love will tear us apart".
Tomb of the Ribaudo family, monumental cemetery of Genoa, Italy, famous for the cover of the single of the English band Joy Division's "Love will tear us apart".  faber1893/Shutterstock.com

People disagree all the time, but not all disagreements lead to the same levels of stress.

Even though people can be passionate about their favorite sport teams, they can argue about which basketball team is the best without destroying friendships. In the workplace, co-workers can often dispute strategies and approaches without risking a long-term fallout.

Political conversations, on the other hand, seem to have become especially challenging in recent years. The prospect alone can make you want to avoid the person altogether. Stories of tense Thanksgiving dinners and of Facebook friends being unfriended have become commonplace.

Why does this happen?

Our research – and related research in political psychology – suggest two broad answers.

First, our work shows that divisive topics – issues that are polarizing, or on which there’s no general societywide consensus – can evoke feelings of anxiety and threat. That is, simply considering these topics appears to put people on guard.

Second, research on moral conviction by psychologist Linda Skitka and her colleagues suggests that attitudes linked to moral values can contribute to social distancing. In other words, if someone considers their position on an issue to be a question of right versus wrong or good versus evil, they’re less likely to want to interact with a person who disagrees on that issue.

An automatic trigger of anxiety

In our research, we define divisive issues as ones that don’t have a clear consensus.

For example, just about everyone supports food safety; but if you bring up issues like abortion or capital punishment, you’ll see people fall into opposing camps.

People also like to have a general idea of where someone falls on an issue before they start debating it. If you’re talking with a stranger, you don’t know how to anticipate their position on a divisive topic. This creates an uncertainty that can be uncomfortable.

With this framework in mind, behavioral scientist Joseph Simons and I designed a series of studies to explore how this plays out.

In our first study, we simply asked individuals to look at a list of 60 social issues (ranging from safe tap water to slavery) and estimated what percentage of people are in favor of that issue. Participants also rated how much they would feel anxious, threatened, interested or relaxed when discussing that issue.

As expected, people thought they would feel more anxious and threatened when discussing a topic that was generally considered more divisive. (Under some circumstances – such as when people didn’t hold a strong attitude on the issue themselves – they did feel somewhat more interested in discussing these topics.)

In a second study, we investigated the experience of threat at an unconscious level. That is, do divisive topics automatically trigger anxiety?

We conducted an experiment that was based on the psychological finding that people don’t always recognize the source of their emotional responses. Feelings that are evoked by one event or object can “carry over” to an unrelated judgment. In this study, we presented participants with a popular topic (for example, supporting veterans), an unpopular topic (high unemployment) or a divisive topic (stem cell research). They then saw a neutral computer-generated picture of a face and had to quickly rate how threatening the face appeared.

Participants were more likely to see a neutral face as threatening if they were thinking about a divisive topic. (Unpopular topics showed a similar effect.)

A third study replicated these effects using fictitious polling data about direct-to-consumer drug advertising. We told some participants that there was a high public consensus about support for this sort of advertising, and we told others that there was wide disagreement. Specifically, we told them that either 20 percent, 50 percent or 80 percent of the public was in favor of these ads.

Participants then imagined discussing the issue and reported how they would feel. As in previous studies, those who were told there was more disagreement tended to feel more threatened or anxious about the prospect of discussing the issue.

‘Right and wrong’ adds a layer of complication

An additional social obstacle goes beyond mere disagreement. Consider two individuals who oppose the death penalty.

One person may think that the death penalty is morally wrong, whereas the other person may believe that the death penalty is ineffective at deterring crime. Although both individuals may strongly support their position, the first person holds this attitude with moral conviction.

Research by Skitka and her colleagues highlights the social consequences of these “moral mandates.” When it’s a matter of right or wrong, people become less tolerant of others who hold the opposite view. Specifically, individuals with stronger moral convictions tended to not want to associate with those who disagreed with them on certain issues. This social distancing was reflected both in survey responses – “would be happy to be friends with this person” – and even physical distance, like placing a chair farther away from a person with an opposing view.

Of course, no one is ever going to agree on every issue. But it’s important for people to learn about where others are coming from in order to reach a compromise.

Unfortunately, compromise or consensus is more difficult to come by if people start out the conversation feeling threatened. And if individuals feel that someone who holds an opposite view is simply a bad person, the conversation may never happen at all.

In the end, it doesn’t matter if you’re talking to a stranger or friends; the possibility of exclusion or avoidance increases when a divisive topic is raised.

There’s no easy solution. Sometimes raising these topics may reveal irreconcilable differences. But other times, a willingness to approach difficult topics calmly – while truly listening to the other side – may help people find common ground or promote change.

The ConversationIt might also be helpful to take a step back. A disagreement on a single issue – even a morally charged one – isn’t necessarily grounds for discontinuing a friendship. On the other hand, focusing on other shared bonds and morals can salvage or strengthen the relationship.

About The Author

Melanie Green, Associate Professor of Communication, University at Buffalo, The State University of New York

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Related Books

Non Violent Communication: An Art of Peaceful Communication: 50 + Proven Tips for Nonviolent Communication, action, atonement & Nonviolent Resistance (Nonviolent ... Atonement, Nonviolent Resistance)

communicationAuthor: Flora Butler
Binding: Kindle Edition
Format: Kindle eBook

Buy Now
Editorial Review:

Learn how to communicate peacefully for positive results in life

Today only, get this Amazon book for just $0.99. Regularly priced at $4.99. Read on your PC, Mac, smart phone, tablet or Kindle device.

You would have realized many times during your life that you have missed an important opportunity. Did it happen to you anytime that you have ruined important aspect of your life just because of your short temper or rude behaviour? For example, suppose that you are going to get a promotion in your job, but suddenly you boss blames you for not completing your work properly and you shouted at him. You lost an easy chance of promotion and on the other hand, you lost your boss’s preference. You are no more in the good books of your boss. We ruin our life many times like this just because of our short tempered behaviour and that’s why we must learn the non-violent communication for successful life and relations.

Learning non-violent communication is very important for the people like you who often face the problem of anger. Anger is not good for your health and also your well being. You would have realized in your life that you lost many relations just because of your anger. We often blame other people about their rude behaviour, but we never realized that sometimes we ourselves are more responsible for the awkward situation than another person. Non-violent communication is the best way to deal with ill mannered people in our life. Many people in our life are somewhat important and we cannot totally neglect them. We must learn how to cope in different situations to live a happy and peaceful life.

Non-violent communication is an art of learning how to send and receive messages. Now, there are two important questions in these messages: What is alive within us? And what should be done to make our life more beautiful? Nonviolent communication is a specific approach to communicating, listening, and speaking that leads us to provide everything from our heart, thereby allowing our natural compassion to flourish.
Learning non-violent communication requires great honesty, openness, developing a certain degree of expressions, and thereby overcoming deeply ingrained learning that should contain judgement, fear, obligation, duty, fear, punishment, and reward. Everything we do is the outcome of our requirements. Whenever we apply this view to others, then we will see that we don’t have any real enemies. The behaviour of other people towards us is the best possible thing they know to do to get their requirements met.

Let’s get started…..
Download your copy today!
Take action today and download this book for a limited time discount of only $0.99! Hurry Up!!

Tags- Nonviolent Communication, Nonviolent Action, Nonviolent Atonement, Nonviolent Resistance, Nonviolent Communication A Language of Life, Living Nonviolent Communication

Communication in Marriage: How to Communicate with Your Spouse Without Fighting

communicationAuthor: Marcus Kusi
Binding: Audible Audiobook
Format: Unabridged
  • Greg Zarcone
  • Our Peaceful Family

Studio: Our Peaceful Family
Label: Our Peaceful Family
Publisher: Our Peaceful Family
Manufacturer: Our Peaceful Family

Buy Now
Editorial Review:

How to communicate with your spouse without fighting - even if you have a difficult spouse

Do you find it difficult communicating with your spouse? Are you tired of arguing and fighting with your spouse whenever you try to communicate? Is your spouse not talking to you anymore?

You are not alone.

Many couples (including us) have had to deal with these communication problems at some point in marriage, and it's not fun! The yelling, shouting, anger, frustration, resentment.... It can definitely be overwhelming.

It could even destroy your ability to not only communicate effectively with your spouse, but also enjoy your marriage.

But don't worry.

No matter what communication problems you struggle with, you can learn how to communicate effectively with your spouse today.

Whether you feel you are not being heard, cannot hear your spouse, or want to communicate better with your spouse without fighting or yelling, this book will show you how.

For the past seven years, we have used these communication skills to go from arguing and fighting whenever we communicated to communicating effectively without fighting, calling each other names, or being disrespectful.

In this book, you will learn:

  1. How to communicate with your spouse without fighting
  2. How to improve communication in your marriage
  3. To clearly understand why we all communicate differently
  4. Why trust is an essential aspect of effective communication in marriage
  5. How to communicate through conflict, even with a difficult spouse
  6. Our simple step-by-step plan for effective communication in seven days or less
  7. How to communicate through difficult emotions
  8. How to prevent communication problems with your spouse
  9. Why your past experiences affect the way you communicate with your spouse.

This book will show you proven communication skills married couples need to communicate effectively with each other.

We have tested and continue to use these effective communication skills in our marriage every single day. And they work!

Whether you feel like you cannot communicate with your spouse, or improve communication in your marriage, you can become a better communicator in your marriage by listening to this book today.

You don't need another fight or argument!

You can communicate better with your husband or wife.

How would your marriage be different if you had no communication problems?

Peaceful Conversations - Preventing Conflict in Communication: Across cultures, In the workplace, Among family & friends

communicationAuthor: Dr. Gail Nemetz Robinson PhD
Binding: Paperback
Studio: RiversMoore Books
Label: RiversMoore Books
Publisher: RiversMoore Books
Manufacturer: RiversMoore Books

Buy Now
Editorial Review: You never listen… It's your fault… They're all thieves… Get to the point… Don't be so abrupt... If these sound familiar as speaker or listener then Peaceful Conversations is sure to help. One of the greatest challenges facing society today is how to develop peaceful communication, empathy and mutual understanding. Entire communities are being stereotyped and targeted for hate. In the political arena, differences of opinion turn into violence. In the workplace, simple differences in communication style cause loss of clients and jobs. Children, parents, couples and friends sit around a dinner table or college dorm feeling that they are not heard or understood. Some become estranged. Even for the well-intended, automatic psychological roadblocks and cultural differences in speech styles obstruct our best efforts. We exclude others as a matter of course —in the boardroom, on the school playground, in three-party conversations. In the heat of emotional upset or a self-serving desire to win, the goal of our conversation often gets lost. Peaceful Conversations offers a wellness approach to communication in an attempt to head off conflict, before it begins. What makes up empathy, inclusion and effective communication? How can we overcome the psychological traps that cause us to blame and stereotype others? How can we apply respect for diversity to conversation practices? Through original research and findings of experts, tempered with entertaining anecdotes, Peaceful Conversations provides practical solutions proven to lift communication roadblocks and ease the way to peaceful communication from the bedroom to the boardroom, both here and abroad. The strategies will help in preventing squabbles at the dinner table, getting that raise at work, making a new friend in a local market abroad, or just becoming a more empathetic friend, lover, parent or child who can communicate criticism without decimating the listener. Soon available in Spanish as Conversaciones Pacíficas.


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email


follow InnerSelf on


 Get The Latest By Email