Momo Challenge Shows How Even Experts Are Falling For Digital Hoaxes

technology

Momo Challenge Shows How Even Experts Are Falling For Digital Hoaxes
We all need to get better at spotting fake news.
Panuwat Phimpha/Shutterstock

“An evil suicide game” was how one newspaper described the “Momo challenge”, a so-called game that supposedly involved children receiving a series of threatening and increasingly dangerous instructions from an anonymous contact on their smartphone. Such sensationalist reporting risked whipping up a frenzied panic, and it soon became apparent there was little evidence the game was real, with one children’s organisation saying it had received more enquiries from the press than from parents.

It’s easy to see why parents would be worried by reports of this purported phenomena, which are accompanied by a particularly creepy image of a doll reminiscent of something from a Japanese horror film. But the Momo challenge is simply the latest digital hoax, an urban legend able to develop and gain momentum because of the sharing of videos, articles and warnings online.

The intention of most people issuing these warnings is usually well-meaning. But the failure of people to identify the hoax, even by those who should have expert insight into whether children really are in danger, helps to create a problem where none really existed. And it’s likely to be worried parents that are harmed as a result rather than their more digital savvy children.

Reports of suicides linked to the Momo challenge have appeared around the world since July 2018, but without solid evidence that any of the deaths recorded were actually caused by the game. Attention on the story has grown, and recently took off in the British press after a mother posted a warning about it on her local Facebook group. She’d not seen any actual evidence of the game but had researched it after her son heard rumours about it at school and watched videos about it online.

It wasn’t just the media and parents that were sucked in, however. Children’s charities have criticised schools for warning parents about the challenge, and an MP raised the issue in parliament after being contacted by worried parents. Even the police were not immune from getting swept up in the panic, with several forces issuing dire warnings about Momo.

The irony is that there never was any proof of Momo. But now, partly as a result of the media attention, Momo has shifted from its supposed existence in threatening WhatsApp messages into a widely visible meme across YouTube and other online sources. And enough detail is available to equip those so inclined to use Momo as a method of cyberbullying.

Even as the media coverage shifted to articles condemning the Momo challenge as fake news and criticising the surrounding frenzy, reports still tended to include the image of the bulging-eyed female, perpetuating the clickbait cycle. This “visual extra” intensifies public awareness and ensures that the story registers in the collective imagination. In terms of the potential for harm, it has almost become irrelevant whether Momo was originally genuine or a hoax.

Heard this one before?

If the Momo challenge sounds familiar it’s because it’s very similar to the Blue Whale game that went viral in 2017, with headlines claiming that that had also led to the death of more than 130 teenagers. As with Momo, there was little verified information to prove these claims.

And yet the story was again able to draw in those who should have greeted it more sceptically. Much of the subsequent academic analysis of the Blue Whale game tended to uncritically accept the existence of the challenge and its purported link to suicides. There has been little attempt to understand how digital hoaxes are perpetuated and validated through the process of online warnings.

Even researchers who have analysed the presence of the Blue Whale game on social media have drawn inferences about it being “a deadly online craze” and “taking the world by storm” – claims that are not supported by the research. The most critical analysis of the Blue Whale game and how it proliferated in the news media came from journalists, not academics.

Momo Challenge Shows How Even Experts Are Falling For Digital Hoaxes
Ollyy/Shutterstock

With all the online risks to children highlighted in the media, parents now have added responsibilities and expectations to protect their children than previous generations. It is difficult enough to navigate through the cacophony of drama to verify facts in an age of fake news. And this is made even harder when misinformation comes from supposedly expert and reputable sources.

But ultimately, digital hoaxes have as much if not more chance of causing emotional harm to parents or carers who may not have the same appreciation of internet culture as their children do. As the author Don Tapscott argues in his book Grown up Digital, the so-called “net generation” are often good at scrutinising information they encounter online, exposing hoaxes quickly, and making short work of false pretences.

Of course this applies more to older children and teenagers. But the pressure and desire to protect children from the horrors of the internet could inadvertently cause parents to engage with, or expose their children to, distressing content they would not have otherwise.

Digital hoaxes highlight the need for everyone to think more critically about online information. Often the hype can distract us from the real online issues affecting children and young people and the need for greater advice and support for suicide prevention in general.The Conversation

About The Authors

Lisa Sugiura, Senior Lecturer in Criminology and Cybercrime, University of Portsmouth and Anne Kirby, Research Associate, University of Portsmouth

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Related Books

Wolfrat Learns the Dangers of the Internet: Youthapedia - The Adventures of Humble Jungle

technologyAuthor: YanFran MoeDancey
Binding: Paperback
Studio: Bowker
Label: Bowker
Publisher: Bowker
Manufacturer: Bowker

Buy Now
Editorial Review: A soda, some chips, and the internet. Things that Wolfrat uses to stay cool and relaxed. But even in Humble Jungle, the Internet can be a dangerous neighborhood for the Jellybeans. From cyber-predators to social media posts that can come back to haunt them later in life, the hazards can be frightening. Wolfrat unwittingly exposes himself to online risks. Youthapedia - The Adventures of Humble Jungle's Wolfrat Learns the Dangers of the Internet teaches young readers the importance of avoiding strangers online, and what to do if a stranger does try to talk to them. Awesome artwork attracts readers, while the intriguing story reinforces the keys to Internet safety. Promoting responsible online use, is the focus of this fun yet informative resource for young Internet users.




Stranger Danger: Children Beware

technologyAuthor: Vickie Vernon Hawkins
Binding: Paperback
Features:
  • Used Book in Good Condition

Brand: Brand: Trafford Publishing
Studio: Trafford Publishing
Label: Trafford Publishing
Publisher: Trafford Publishing
Manufacturer: Trafford Publishing

Buy Now
Editorial Review:
Since when did a grown-up think a child is the boss? Stay away from that car, or in you'll be tossed!
When Adam Walsh was kidnapped and murdered in 1981, fear gripped the nation. It was unfathomable to think that a child could be abducted in a shopping mall with his mother near. Some thirty years ago, Vickie Vernon Hawkins was a young mother whose third child had just been born. The realization that such a horrific abduction and subsequent murder could happen to anyone-anywhere-became an integral part of the way she raised her children. As she urged them to always remember, "Stranger danger ... we must beware!" she began creating catchy rhymes that would help children as young as age two know exactly what to say and do when their safety is threatened by a stranger who asks for directions, offers candy, or touches a private place. The simple rhymes, accompanying illustrations, and practical advice in Stranger Danger: Children Beware blend to create a life-saving and lasting impression in the eyes and minds of children.
If a stranger should knock, keep the door locked!




Raising Net Safe Kids: The Dangers That Lurk Online Enticing Our Children and Teens

technologyAuthor: Ryan Pacheco
Binding: Kindle Edition
Format: Kindle eBook
Studio: 10-41 Publishing
Label: 10-41 Publishing
Publisher: 10-41 Publishing
Manufacturer: 10-41 Publishing

Buy Now
Editorial Review: In it's first three days of release this book was an Amazon #1 Best Seller. “Every parent should read this book...Technology is a moving target but this resource can help parents be better parents.”
Gary Raney-Former Ada County, Idaho Sheriff

"As sophisticated as teenagers are online- constant vigil is imperative- and this book offers insightful and heart wrenching examples of how otherwise tech savvy kids can be emotionally, socially and physically manipulated -because at heart - they are still just kids."
First Lady of the State of Idaho, Lori Otter

Read about real cases, juvenile behaviors online and what parents need to know to make their kids online experience safer. Detective Ryan Pacheco (Ret.) is an Author, Public Speaker, Consultant and retired Detective from the Ada County Sheriff’s Office in Boise, Idaho. He worked in the Criminal Investigations, Persons Crimes Division and was a member of the Idaho Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force Assigned to the Idaho Attorney General's Office.
He formed the High Risk Juvenile Victims Unit at the Ada County Sheriff's Office and was President of the Idaho Crimes Against Children Conference in 2011 and 2012.

Detective Pacheco (Ret.) has received hundreds of hours of specialized training regarding the online sexual exploitation of children. This training included multiple investigative schools about online sexual exploitation of children, Internet Crimes Against Children investigative techniques, and peer-to-peer (P2P) software training. He has attended training specifically regarding investigating human trafficking,

Pacheco is an Author, Public Speaker, Consultant, Business Owner, and Administrator of RaisingNetSafeKids.com, an online website dedicated to providing parents with resources for internet safety for kids, which includes free blog postings, webinars, and online educational courses. He hosts free online webinars and sends out information via newsletter. More information can be found at RaisingNetSafeKids.com.

"Respond rather than react. Help is on the way. Read this book - follow the author’s directions. He may help you save your child’s life."
Dennis Mansfield, Author of "Beautiful Nate"




technology
enafarzh-CNzh-TWtlfrdehiiditjamsptrues

follow InnerSelf on

google-plus-iconfacebook-icontwitter-iconrss-icon

 Get The Latest By Email

{emailcloak=off}

follow InnerSelf on

google-plus-iconfacebook-icontwitter-iconrss-icon

 Get The Latest By Email

{emailcloak=off}