Loneliness, a universal human experience, often conjures images of an aching heart yearning for connection. However, recent insights suggest that our understanding of loneliness requires a more profound examination beyond the need to belong. This article explores the compelling findings of the Irish Longitudinal Study on Aging, shedding light on how the fulfillment of two crucial human needs - communion and agency - plays a pivotal role in our experience of loneliness.

Understanding Communion and Agency

Central to our social existence are two fundamental needs: communion and agency. Communion represents our innate yearning to establish and maintain connections with others. This drive goes beyond mere socializing; it encompasses the desire to fit in and to be part of a community. It's the underpinning force that leads us to seek out friendships, to be part of a family or a group, and to foster a sense of belonging.

Being friendly, trustworthy, and moral are desirable traits and essential components of communion. They are the qualities that allow us to build and sustain meaningful relationships, creating a sense of warmth and belonging that is vital for our emotional well-being.

On the other hand, agency is the compelling need to assert our individuality. It's about having the autonomy to make our own choices and the freedom to chart our course in life. This need drives us to pursue goals that are not just imposed by societal norms but are deeply personal and meaningful. Agency is about being the author of our story and controlling our decisions and actions. It's a crucial aspect of our identity and self-esteem, empowering us to achieve our full potential.

In the tapestry of human experience, agency and communion intertwine, each playing a vital role in shaping our social interactions and sense of self. Together, they form a delicate balance, influencing how we connect with others while maintaining our unique individuality.

innerself subscribe graphic

The Irish Longitudinal Study on Aging: Key Data

The Irish Longitudinal Study on Aging, conducted from October 2009 to February 2011, offers an enlightening perspective. Engaging a diverse group of 8,500 participants aged 49 to 80, the study meticulously gathered data on various aspects of their lives, including economic status, health, relationships, and employment. This comprehensive approach allowed for a nuanced understanding of how different facets of life intertwine with feelings of loneliness.

From this rich dataset emerged a four-prototype model, categorizing individuals based on their experiences of communion and agency. This model serves as a lens to view how varying degrees of communion and agency correlate with feelings of loneliness:

* The 'Empowered' enjoy supportive relationships alongside a sense of choice and autonomy.

* The 'Separated' have moderate support but are nudged towards self-sufficiency.

* The 'Neglected' face the double whammy of scant warm relations and a lack of autonomy.

* The 'Muted' have supportive ties yet minimal personal control.

Analyzing Loneliness Through the Four-Prototype Model

The study's findings are revelatory. Loneliness does not exist in a vacuum but is influenced by the interplay of communion and agency. Those categorized as 'Neglected,' experiencing low levels of agency and communion, reported the highest loneliness scores. Conversely, the 'Empowered' group, with high levels of both, showed the lowest scores. This pattern underscores the complex nature of loneliness, transcending mere social connection.

Ybarra, a notable figure in this field, emphasizes that loneliness is traditionally viewed as a deficit in communion needs. However, this study brings to light the equally significant role of agency. The need for personal control, choice, and autonomy is a vital component of our social well-being. Ignoring this aspect can lead to a skewed understanding of loneliness and, consequently, inadequate solutions.

Practical Approaches to Addressing Loneliness

Combatting loneliness requires a nuanced and multifaceted strategy beyond mere social interaction. It involves creating an environment that provides emotional warmth and support and respects and nurtures an individual's autonomy and decision-making. This approach recognizes that people need more than just company; they need to feel understood and valued for their unique selves.

By acknowledging and fostering a sense of control and choice in individuals, we help them feel empowered in their social interactions. This empowerment is vital in alleviating feelings of isolation and helplessness that often accompany loneliness. It's about balancing being supportive in someone's life and giving them the space and respect to make their own choices and pursue their interests.

Furthermore, it's essential to establish a sense of security and belonging for individuals, offering them a haven amidst the tumult of life. This means ensuring that people know they have a dependable support system to fall back on when they face challenges. It's about providing a shoulder to lean on and fostering an environment where individuals feel free to express themselves and explore their identities without fear of judgment. Such an environment encourages personal growth and self-discovery, crucial in overcoming loneliness. By combining empathy and respect for individuality, we can create a supportive community that not only alleviates loneliness but also enriches the lives of all its members.

The Irish Longitudinal Study on Aging insights urge us to reconsider our understanding of loneliness. Recognizing the crucial roles of communion and agency opens new pathways to addressing this complex emotion. As we navigate our social landscapes, we must remember that our need for connection is intertwined with our desire for autonomy and control. Embracing this duality can lead us to more holistic and practical approaches to combating loneliness, fostering a society where everyone feels genuinely connected and empowered.

The study appears in Frontiers of Social Psychology.


Books Improving Attitude and Behavior from Amazon's Best Sellers list

"Atomic Habits: An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones"

by James Clear

In this book, James Clear presents a comprehensive guide to building good habits and breaking bad ones. The book includes practical advice and strategies for creating lasting behavior change, based on the latest research in psychology and neuroscience.

Click for more info or to order

"Unf*ck Your Brain: Using Science to Get Over Anxiety, Depression, Anger, Freak-Outs, and Triggers"

by Faith G. Harper, PhD, LPC-S, ACS, ACN

In this book, Dr. Faith Harper offers a guide to understanding and managing common emotional and behavioral issues, including anxiety, depression, and anger. The book includes information on the science behind these issues, as well as practical advice and exercises for coping and healing.

Click for more info or to order

"The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do in Life and Business"

by Charles Duhigg

In this book, Charles Duhigg explores the science of habit formation and how habits impact our lives, both personally and professionally. The book includes stories of individuals and organizations who have successfully changed their habits, as well as practical advice for creating lasting behavior change.

Click for more info or to order

"Tiny Habits: The Small Changes That Change Everything"

by BJ Fogg

In this book, BJ Fogg presents a guide to creating lasting behavior change through small, incremental habits. The book includes practical advice and strategies for identifying and implementing tiny habits that can lead to big changes over time.

Click for more info or to order

"The 5 AM Club: Own Your Morning, Elevate Your Life"

by Robin Sharma

In this book, Robin Sharma presents a guide to maximizing your productivity and potential by starting your day early. The book includes practical advice and strategies for creating a morning routine that supports your goals and values, as well as inspiring stories of individuals who have transformed their lives through early rising.

Click for more info or to order